“She Just Disappeared”: Fever Star Sophie Cunningham Breaks Silence on DeWanna Bonner’s Shocking Exit, Reveals Teammates Were Ghosted

In the world of professional sports, player transactions are a part of life. Trades, releases, and free agency moves are announced with sterile press releases, but behind the scenes, there are unwritten rules of conduct. A text to the team group chat, a quiet word with the captains, a handshake goodbye—these small gestures maintain the bonds of a locker room. So when a player of DeWanna Bonner’s stature seemingly vanishes from a team mid-season, the silence that follows can be deafening. Now, Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham has finally broken that silence, revealing the unsettling truth behind Bonner’s abrupt and controversial exit from the team.

The stage had been set for a triumphant season in Indiana. After drafting the phenomenal Caitlin Clark, the front office made a series of savvy moves to surround her with proven talent. They signed a trio of accomplished veterans: Natasha Howard, Sophie Cunningham, and the legendary scorer DeWanna Bonner. On paper, it was a masterstroke, the perfect blend of youth and experience destined to make a deep playoff run. For two-thirds of that equation, the plan worked flawlessly. But for Bonner, the Indiana chapter was a brief, turbulent, and ultimately mystifying ordeal.

After just nine games in a Fever uniform, Bonner disappeared from the lineup. The official reason given was “personal reasons.” She missed five consecutive games as speculation swirled. Then came the quiet announcement: the Indiana Fever had released her. Bonner, a two-time WNBA champion and five-time All-Star, was gone as quickly as she had arrived, eventually latching on with her former team, the Phoenix Mercury. The Fever organization remained tight-lipped, and the players were silent. The mystery lingered, until now.

Speaking on a recent podcast episode, Sophie Cunningham, one of the other key veterans signed alongside Bonner, finally provided the answers fans had been craving. Her tone wasn’t malicious, but her words painted a stark picture of a professional “ghosting.”

“I’m still rooting for her, I want her to be happy—but I also think it’s okay to be professional about it,” Cunningham stated, choosing her words carefully. “Send a text to your teammates, ‘Hey guys, sorry this didn’t work out, good luck, etc.’ There’s a way to handle that, I think.”

The host then asked for clarification: Was there any explanation given to the rest of the team? Cunningham’s confirmation was blunt. There was none. Bonner had simply left without a word.

Cunningham explained that the fit in Indiana was never right for Bonner, suggesting the veteran star was unhappy from the start. “She got to Indiana, and she really wasn’t happy,” Cunningham shared. “I want people to be happy, so that’s why I’m kind of neutral on this one, which a lot of people are surprised about.”

Her neutrality speaks volumes. It’s the sound of a teammate trying to balance empathy for a colleague’s personal struggles with the frustration of being left high and dry. A professional locker room is a workplace, but it’s also an ecosystem built on trust and communication. To have a key member abandon the project without so much as a farewell note is a profound breach of that trust. It leaves the remaining players to pick up the pieces, wondering what went wrong.

The irony is that the Fever haven’t missed a beat. In fact, one could argue the team chemistry has solidified in Bonner’s absence. While she was gone, and with Caitlin Clark also sidelined by injury, the team went on an incredible winning streak. The other two offseason acquisitions, Cunningham and Natasha Howard, have been instrumental in that success. They have integrated seamlessly into the team culture, providing the exact veteran leadership and on-court grit the front office had envisioned. Their success serves as a stark contrast to Bonner’s failed tenure, highlighting that talent alone does not guarantee a successful fit.

Cunningham’s revelations raise important questions about professionalism and happiness in sports. While every athlete has the right to prioritize their mental well-being, a team dynamic requires a level of accountability. Her comments suggest the Fever locker room felt that, at a minimum, a simple courtesy was owed. The situation underscores the delicate balance teams must strike when building a roster, proving that chemistry and culture are just as valuable as points and rebounds. For the Indiana Fever, losing a future Hall of Famer mid-season should have been a devastating blow. Instead, it seems to have been an act of addition by subtraction, removing a piece that didn’t fit and allowing the rest of the puzzle to lock into place more securely than ever before.