Media Firestorm Erupts Over CBS Interview With Erika Kirk as Critics Cry “Staged Theater”

A storm of criticism has erupted online following CBS News’ heavily promoted exclusive interview with Erika Kirk, with commentators accusing the network of producing a scripted media spectacle rather than a legitimate journalistic examination.

The backlash began after CBS released a promotional clip featuring journalist Bari Weiss teasing an hour-long sit-down with Kirk. In the promo, Weiss claimed they discussed “everything,” including grief, political violence, and conspiracies surrounding Kirk’s husband’s assassination. However, critics were quick to argue that the interview avoided the most pressing and uncomfortable questions surrounding the case.

Online commentators mocked the promo’s “walk-and-talk” newsroom aesthetic, calling it performative and theatrical rather than investigative. Many accused CBS of prioritizing optics over substance, arguing the segment resembled a staged production more than an independent journalistic inquiry.

The sharpest criticism centered on what was allegedly not asked. Commentators questioned why the interview failed to address apparent security lapses on the day of the assassination, including how the shooter allegedly accessed a rooftop undetected, why surveillance measures failed, and why bystanders reportedly noticed the suspect before authorities did. Others pointed to inconsistencies surrounding confiscated SD cards, drone usage by security teams, and conflicting official statements—issues they claim remain unresolved.

Critics also questioned Kirk’s public posture of forgiveness toward her husband’s alleged killer, contrasting it with her hostility toward independent investigators and skeptics. “Why is forgiveness extended so easily to the alleged perpetrator,” one commentator asked, “but not to those asking legitimate questions?”

The reaction to CBS’s promotional post was swift and brutal. Despite garnering more than 2.5 million views on social media, the video received only a fraction of that engagement in likes, while comments overwhelmingly criticized both the interviewer and the network. Many users accused CBS of pushing propaganda, protecting powerful interests, and insulating Kirk from scrutiny.

Some critics went further, alleging conflicts of interest tied to corporate media ownership and ideological alignment, claims that CBS has not addressed. Others accused the network of monetizing tragedy, questioning whether advertising revenue was generated from the segment and labeling the interview a “grift.”

CBS News has not publicly responded to the criticism, nor has Weiss addressed claims that the interview questions were provided in advance. Kirk has also remained silent amid growing skepticism online.

As trust in legacy media continues to erode, the controversy highlights a broader frustration among viewers who feel mainstream outlets increasingly favor curated narratives over adversarial journalism. Whether the CBS interview succeeds in restoring credibility or deepens public distrust remains to be seen—but the reaction so far suggests many viewers are no longer willing to accept glossy storytelling in place of hard questions.